From the TUC

A New Year Message

30 Dec 2008, by Guest in Economics

2009 has to mark a decisive turning point, away from the neo-liberal market-always-knows-best conventional wisdom that brought our economy to the brink of a catastrophic collapse, towards a fairer, more balanced economy delivering sustainable prosperity.

This is going to be a grim year. Unemployment will increase every month. Some predict it will hit three million, but in truth no-one knows.

First because we have little experience of a recession driven by a financial collapse, and secondly because we do not know how bold our Government – and as importantly, other governments meeting together as the G20 in April in London – will be.

Government therefore has three priorities in the year ahead:

  • it must take every action necessary to make the recession as short and as shallow as possible;
  • it must develop the proper policy response to mass unemployment;
  • it must use these and other policies not just to ensure that we do not repeat the mistakes that led to the financial collapse, but also to ensure that we emerge from recession as a fairer, greener and more sustainable economy.

Action to tackle the recession

The Government must be prepared to take further bold action to counter the recession and to save jobs.

The roots of this recession lie in the failure of the finance and banking sectors, and while the Government deserves praise for setting the international pace on the bail-out of banks, we do not yet have a banking system that is truly serving the interests of business or household borrowers. Banks are putting building up their own balance sheets and paying back government loans as their top priorities. But they also still hold high levels of ‘toxic’ debts which prevent them from dealing with other banks in a normal way. The Government and the Bank of England must therefore consider injecting even more support into the financial system to get credit flowing again.

The Government cannot be expected to come to the aid of every company that faces difficulties but it must be prepared to look at providing short term assistance to strategic companies in sectors vital to the future of Britain.

The Government should consider a further stimulus package in the Budget. Barack Obama’s team are already talking of a big package to boost the US economy. The UK should follow suit – and also use the April G20 summit in London to create a coalition of the willing to wage war on unemployment, poverty and recession.

As well as bringing forward planned infrastructure projects, ministers should be fast tracking new projects to ensure that further work can start when these finish. The UK is still suffering from a lack of investment in the key infrastructure a modern low-carbon economy requires.

Action to help the unemployed

Too much government policy towards the unemployed still tends to be trapped in the idea that there are enough jobs to go round, and that the unemployed either lack the skills or the motivation to get work. While of course with rights come responsibilities, the thousands of people losing their jobs every week throughout 2009 should not be treated as potential scroungers but victims of economic forces well beyond their control. They will need help through benefits and support through training and job search.

Despite its tough presentation and some objectionable policies such as workfare, there were some good proposals in the welfare reform Green Paper to make Job Centre Plus services better tailored to individual needs. Mass unemployment will make it even harder for those who normally find it more difficult to get work such as disabled people and those juggling child care and work. There needs to be specific help for such groups – such as an increase in child care, which in turn creates jobs.

The TUC has already called for better benefits, higher statutory redundancy pay and a bigger tax allowance for redundancy pay to provide more help for the newly unemployed. We now look for action in the Budget on these issues.

Action to create a fairer, greener and more sustainable economy

2009 is going to be tough, but it can still be made positive if it becomes a turning point – the year in which we set out to build a deliberately different kind of economy.

That first means recognising the mistakes of the past – made not just by this Government, but by governments and the economic and political establishment almost everywhere.

We have given far too much weight to the interests of the finance sector, and began to believe it could create wealth simply by moving it around, rather than through long-term investment in the goods and services that people want and need.

The challenges we face are clear. Even before the recession we were scarred by poverty, particularly child poverty. Our society was coming under increasing strain from growing inequality as a new class of the super-rich escaped their responsibilities to pay a fair share of tax. We had neglected important sectors of the economy as we gave preference to financial services. We have failed to do enough to meet the environmental imperative.

This challenges us all to put the measures we will need to beat the recession to a longer term purpose of building a better greener and fairer economy that can emerge the other side of the downturn.

This will require:

  • a new kind of industrial strategy – not a return to picking winners and easy hand-outs, but strategic support to the sectors where we are already strong but could do better. Some will be in manufacturing, but others will be in services and parts of the economy often neglected in such discussions such as the creative sectors.
  • A green industrial revolution that recognises that many industries will have to adapt to survive, but that also that the environmental challenge can generate thousands of productive worthwhile jobs, and build on the strength of our science base.
  • An intensification of efforts to make society fairer – the recession should encourage the government to speed up efforts to eliminate child poverty.
  • A fairer tax system. The government is right to increase borrowing to maintain the strength of the economy. But this borrowing and decent public services will have to be paid for, and 2009 must see a real debate on how to make the tax system fairer. There is a real demand for the super-rich to pay a fairer share. President Elect Obama has been a long-time supporter of a crack down on the tax havens used by multi-nationals and the mobile super-rich to avoid tax.
  • A new kind of banking system that no longer threatens international economic stability and instead serves the rest of the economy and society. Britain’s banks already look very different. Some are now state-owned, some have large public stakes and all have received substantial help from the Bank of England and the taxpayer. At the very least we will need new regulatory structures to enforce stability but also to protect the consumer in a sector with less competition.

2009 will not be easy year, but it could be the turning point that will make 2010 not just the start of recovery, but the first steps in building a new economy.

4 Responses to A New Year Message

  1. Robert Day
    Dec 30th 2008, 11:40 am

    Picking out just one issue – Brendan’s very last bullet point – the issue with regulation of the financial sector has been the failure of self-regulation. Many of the problems of the FSA stem from the fact that unlike other sectorial regulators, the FSA is organised as a company, staffed and funded from the banks it regulates, and (if investigative journalism be believed) commanded no respect from that sector.

    So there’s the first change. Nationalise the regulator. Staff it with a cadre of proper public servants with the public service ethos – they can still be found if you look hard enough. And then set the regulator loose to make a few examples, the way other sectorial regulators first created by the Tories have been finally doing of late now that they’ve finally been given the powers and the political steer to do so.

  2. Tax Research UK / A message for 2009
    Dec 30th 2008, 6:57 pm

    […] Barber is looking forward to 2009 on the TUC blog. Amongst the things he says he wants […]

  3. A message for 2009 | called2account
    Dec 31st 2008, 6:15 am

    […] Barber is looking forward to 2009 on the TUC blog. Amongst the things he says he wants […]

  4. Nick Clegg has no way to rebalance economy | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC
    Jan 3rd 2009, 11:49 am

    […] Posted at 10:03 am on 3 Jan 09 by Nigel Nick Clegg’s New Year media offensive overlaps with Brendan Barber’s message in some interesting […]