From the TUC

Government manufacturing strategy: why the FT doesn’t need to let facts get in the way

28 Dec 2009, by in Economics

The Financial Times says Lord Mandelson’s manufacturing strategy is failing to convince manufacturing employers. But they use journalistic sleight of hand to make the evidence fit the story better, suggesting that the FT editorial line of support for tax cutting Tories rather than Labour investors has bled into the news pages. 

According to the FT, only one in three manufacturers contacted (leave aside whether 57 is a representative sample!) “believes the business secretary’s ideas to boost production industries will do any good.”

The table showing the results of the grandly titled “FT manufacturing barometer panel” reveals that 20 said his policies “would help”, and 37 said it was “hard to say” or would be “no help”. But without knowing how many were in each of those two categories, it’s difficult to sustain the thrust of the article, illustrated by 5 quotes (a clearly unrepresentative 4 of them in the “no help” category), that manufacturers oppose his strategy. For all we know, more manufacturers think the ideas will help than not, and there’s no evidence at all that anyone thinks they would actually hinder manufacturing.

Mind you, maybe he was lucky. The finding of the survey that 37 of the 57 thought there would be a recovery in 2010 was illustrated by just 1 quote – saying there wouldn’t!

Why let the facts get in the way when you’ve already decided the story?

2 Responses to Government manufacturing strategy: why the FT doesn’t need to let facts get in the way

  1. Building a coalition for investment in manufacturing | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC
    Dec 28th 2009, 2:44 pm

    […] section of the Financial Times today (possibly because it contradicts the news story which I have already blogged about), is a report of an interview with the head of Corus UK, Kirby Adams. Although probably not the […]

  2. Tweets that mention Government manufacturing strategy: why the FT doesn’t need to let facts get in the way | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC — Topsy.com
    Dec 28th 2009, 3:41 pm

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by ToUChstone blog, TIGMOO. TIGMOO said: ToUChstone blog: Government manufacturing strategy: why the FT doesn’t need to let facts get in the way http://bit.ly/5v7HS9 […]