From the TUC

Safety statistics: They are what you make them

07 Sep 2010, by in Working Life

Last year 151 people were killed at work, or at least that is what HSE statistics show. The press frequently let us know that Britain is one of the safest countries in the world. So what’s the truth? Well it all depends what you mean.

The HSE figures are more or less accurate for what they are meant to show, but it is how they are used that is important. After all they are certainly not the number of people killed by their work or even the number of people killed AT the workplace. They are simply ‘reportable deaths’.

Reportable deaths are those that occur as a result of an injury while at work. It does not however cover people who are driving as part of their work, such as lorry drivers, or sales people. North Sea oil workers are included, but not if they are killed while in a helicopter. Also if a person dies 11 months after the injury they are counted, but not if they die 13 months after.

But the biggest omission is those who are killed by a disease caused by work. In some cases, such as mesothelioma it is usually possible to show that the death is caused as a result of work (asbestos exposure), but in many others it is more difficult, especially in the case of cancers that are widespread in the general population such as breast cancer or lung cancer. That is why you have to estimate the number of cases.

The HSE estimates that just over 8,000 deaths are caused each year by occupational cancers, although many specialists believe that is a considerable underestimation. The TUC has indicated that it believes that a figure of 15,000 would be more realistic.

In addition there are around 4,000 deaths from other lung disorders such as chronic bronchitis and emphysema caused by breathing in fumes chemicals and dusts. There are also all those who die as a result of cardiovascular disease caused by the nature of their work. This can either be stress (which can more than double your risk), or exposure to certain fumes and chemicals. This is much more difficult to assess but an estimated 66,000 people report work-related heart disease each year. Even if only 5% of deaths from cardiovascular disease were to be work related, that would mean that 7,500 people die as a result of health or circulatory problems caused by their work.

If you also include the 1,000+ people who are killed while driving on the roads as part of their work then, using the most conservative estimates, at least 20,000 people die prematurely every year because of occupational injury or disease, but the real figure could be nearer twice that.

That means that the figure that we give for the number of deaths at work is actually well under 1% of the number of people who actually die as a result of their work.

It is the deaths from injury that are the ones that make the newspaper headlines, but a life lost to disease is just as much a tragedy. Because these often take place in a hospice behind closed curtains, often years after the person has left work, there is less awareness, or concern. And it is not only deaths that many people are unaware of. In total, 1,200,000 people currently in work say they suffered from ill-health that they thought was work-related.

Focusing on the official figure of 151 fatalities at work also means that we have a totally unrealistic view of how safe the workplace is. This allows politicians and the media to rubbish health and safety.

It is that reason that the TUC is campaigning to reclaim health and safety from the knockers and those who try to undermine in because it suits their own purpose.

We have just produced a report called The Case for Health and Safety which spells out why health and safety is as relevant today as it has ever been. After all 20,000+ deaths is no laughing matter.

NOTE: You can read the full report at www.tuc.org.uk/caseforhealthandsafety

One Response to Safety statistics: They are what you make them

  1. Peter Hall-Jones
    Sep 13th 2010, 11:50 pm

    Thanks for this excellent review of the data, and the very strange “methodology” that underlies it. Most other countries have counting rituals that are just as misleading. Is there any other industry which would tolerate such irresponsible statistics?