From the TUC

IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible: major step forward for campaign

10 Oct 2010, by in Economics, Environment, International

Yesterday the IMF finally released its study on the financial transactions tax. The paper, a draft of which was leaked a month ago, admits that an FTT is possible, lists the 16 G20 countries who already have one in a limited form, and admits that the more transactions it covers the more effective it will be.

This grudging conversion – much more positive than just a few months ago (and of course a year ago it was dismissed out of hand by the IMF Director-General) – is marred by the IMF’s continued use of studies from 20 years ago – when the financial markets were totally different – which question the impact of FTTs on volatility. The only objection still standing in the way of a G20 decision to implement an FTT is lack of political will.

The IMF policy paper is one of the background papers included in a 200-page report on “Financial Sector Taxation” (pdf, pages 144-187). It acknowledges the feasibility of the FTT and its capacity to raise large amounts of revenue although the Fund favours taxation of financial activities which would raise far less.

The release of the paper coincides with a debate on the FTT that took place Saturday morning as a side event to the IFIs’ annual meetings between the IMF and FTT proponents. (Speakers were Victoria Perry, IMF; Prof. Robert Pollin Uni. of Massachusetts; Peter Bakvis, ITUC/Global Unions). The FTT proponents noted the contributions that the paper made to knowledge about the FTT and suggestions for its specific design, but contested some of the arguments made by the IMF in critiquing the FTT.

Two months ago, the IMF made a version of its FTT study available to Global Unions and other civil society groups who made submissions on the FTT during consultation in early 2010. Only small modifications were made in the study released today.

5 Responses to IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible: major step forward for campaign

  1. Tweets that mention IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible: major step forward for campaign | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC — Topsy.com
    Oct 10th 2010, 9:19 am

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by gemma tumelty , diana smith , diana smith , Oliver Heath, ToUChstone blog and others. ToUChstone blog said: IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible: major step forward for campaign http://bit.ly/bljrpJ […]

  2. Tax Research UK » IMH agrees Robin Hood Tax works
    Oct 11th 2010, 7:37 am

    […] Owen Tudor has noted on the TUC blog: Yesterday the IMF finally released its study on the financial transactions tax. […]

  3. Tweets that mention IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible: major step forward for campaign | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC — Topsy.com
    Oct 11th 2010, 10:00 am

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by NewLeftProject, UK Poverty Post. UK Poverty Post said: Encouraging news as IMF admits Robin Hood Tax is possible – http://bit.ly/ag2QqK – #RHT […]

  4. On the IMF report on a financial transactions tax
    Oct 11th 2010, 11:55 am

    […] Owen Tudor and Richard Murphy both claim that the IMF’s report out today supports their case for a financial transactions tax. […]

  5. Banks benefit from £19bn tax gain « Same old played out scenes
    Oct 18th 2010, 8:11 pm

    […] attention to the tax regime, to whit: greater tax fairness. As regards financial institutions, a financial transactions tax would also go some way towards establishing financial responsibility for the crisis – in the […]