From the TUC

Why CGT should go up

19 Jun 2010, by in Economics

The BBC ignored the TUC’s new guide to Capital Gains Tax yesterday but thought the Adam Smith Institute’s special pleading for the wealthy worthy of report today.

Capital gains tax (CGT) is used by rich people to avoid paying their proper share of tax and if the Chancellor believes that ‘we are all in this together’ he should increase both the rate and coverage of CGT.

Because CGT is levied at 18 per cent and the highest rate of income tax is now 50 per cent, there is a huge incentive for people to use accountancy tricks to turn income into a capital gain.  The TUC guide references official figures which clearly show that CGT is the ‘tax dodger’s tax of choice’:

  • 33 per cent of all tax liable capital gains were held for less than a year.
  • As 60 per cent of all capital gains tax bills are paid by people with little or no income, and the poor do not have the wealth to purchase assets on which they can gain, the strong suspicion must be that assets are being transferred to non-earning spouses to take advantage of a second CGT allowance. It is quite reasonable therefore to think that half of all CGT bills are evidence of tax dodging.
  • Hedge fund and private equity managers are notorious for taking income as ‘carried interest’ on which they pay CGT – this is why they can pay less tax than their cleaners.
  • Capital Gains Tax is an ‘honesty box’ tax – the volume of trades in London shares suggest the CGT tax take should be significantly higher and that many capital gains go unreported to an understaffed HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC).

The Chancellor should increase CGT rates so that they are the same as income tax rates, and that the annual allowance for gains before tax is due should be cut from £10,100 to £2,000 a year as the Liberal Democrat manifesto proposed.

The Chancellor should also crack down on abuse of the exemption for business sales, says the report. While there is a good case for treating people disposing of a business they have built up over many years as a special case, the current low 10 per cent rate for the first million pounds gain on a business asset is abused by hedge funds and private equity.

There also needs to be a major anti-avoidance and evasion programme with more tax inspectors and new requirements to register asset sales. Capital gains on any asset held for less than two years should be taxed under income tax rules.

The vast majority of taxpayers never come into contact with capital gains tax as they are simply not wealthy enough to buy and sell the assets that bring capital gains.

But most will find it incomprehensible that they pay more tax on the wages they earn from putting in a full day’s work than the wealthy do from sitting back and watching their assets increase in value.

CGT is the tax dodger’s tax of choice and is used by the wealthy to pay less tax than their servants. It’s time to get tough with a crackdown on CGT loopholes and make far more effort to stop abuse. Employing more tax inspectors would more than pay for itself in new income.

If the Chancellor is serious about us all being in this together, he should implement in full the Liberal Democrat proposals on CGT.

2 Responses to Why CGT should go up

  1. Tweets that mention Why CGT should go up | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC —
    Jun 19th 2010, 2:06 pm

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by ToUChstone blog and John West, sunny hundal. sunny hundal said: BBC ignored TUC's views on CGT but happily reports Adam Smith Inst. – impartiality you can believe in […]

  2. CGT change is very modest | ToUChstone blog: A public policy blog from the TUC
    Jun 22nd 2010, 1:47 pm

    […] The 28 per cent rate means that there is still a strong incentive to use accountancy tricks to turn income into a capital gain (as we explain here). […]