From the TUC

Now a lost eleven years on pay, unprecedented for at least 150 years *

17 Feb 2016, by in Economics

Real earnings grew in 2015 by 2.5%, a positive figure for the first time since 2007. I.e. 2015 was the first year when pay growth outstripped inflation in 8 years.**

But there is a long way to go: real earnings still stand 5¾% below the 2007 peak.

Projecting forwards using the official forecasts for earnings and inflation, shows real earnings will not recapture their 2007 peak until 2018. At face value the ‘lost decade’ looks like it will now be at eleven years long, and this is on the basis of official projections which are not known for their pessimism.

The level of real earnings (2014 prices)


As we have remarked before, never before in the history I have readily accessible (for which figures extend back to the 1850s) has such a period of decline and stagnation had to be endured. The chart below shows a decade growth rate. Across the whole period real earnings grew on average by 15 per cent a decade. Between the Second World War and 2007 they grew by 26 per cent a decade (annual averages are derived by dividing by ten). In 2017 the decade figure will show a decline of -1.7 per cent. The charts shows how the progress of the post-war age has been brought decisively to a halt.

Real earnings, decade growth rate


The only era remotely comparable episode was around the 1920s. This is a terrifying precedent, covering the economic chaos at the end of the First World War, the disastrous return to the gold standard in 1925, the great depression that began in 1930 and the disastrous ‘May Committee’ spending cuts spending cuts that were imposed in the face of that depression. But even then, real earnings declined for ‘only’ ten years.

The great depression finally taught the world that the only way out of an economic crisis was for governments to manage more deliberately the financial system and to use its own expenditure to help expand the economy. Policymakers today remain oblivious to these lessons. Really the idea that we face even a lost eleven years is based on a forecast of a sustained recovery that on the present course will never come. In the meantime working people are paying a very high price indeed.


*I have changed the title – ‘never before in history’ a bit strong when my data extend only to 1850s. Ta, Ronan Lyons.

** NB I am using the government’s preferred CPI measure; the story is likely to be even worse on the RPI.

3 Responses to Now a lost eleven years on pay, unprecedented for at least 150 years *

  1. Margie
    Feb 18th 2016, 4:49 pm

    And what about public sector pay?

  2. Tony Hart
    Feb 19th 2016, 10:57 am

    We are competing with all the emerging economies, whose wages are far less than ours. In that situation, how can you think that UK wages should increase? You have seen what has happened to our steel industry; you know that we suffer a large trade deficit. Surely either UK wages must reduce or the £ falls out of sight, making imports increase in price. Either way, we have to come to terms with world trade; we are no longer a rich country.

  3. Phil
    Feb 19th 2016, 4:55 pm


    The UK does NOT compete with EM economies. The composition of the UK’s exports are entirely different from EM countries.

    There have always been poor countries in the world. Something else has changed in the interim. Poor policy management and incompetent, self-interested bungling are obviously at the root of this.