From the TUC

Autumn Statement 2016: Chancellor goes a little way to meet his investment challenge

23 Nov 2016, by in Economics

Today the Chancellor has finally recognised that spending on infrastructure strengthens the economy.

Measures the TUC has long called for were announced, including more cash for housing, high speed broadband, rail and roads. Overall the Chancellor’s measures amounted to £23bn, a big sounding number.

But looking at OBR numbers which show public sector net investment a share of GDP gives a different picture.

The new plans take the average investment across the parliament to 2% of GDP, up from 1.7% under the previous plans. But the plans still fall well short of the 2.2% share of spending in the last parliament.

The chart below gives the detail. The red line shows plans as they were at the Budget. The green line shows spending announced today The dotted lines show the new and old averages across the parliament, with the average for the previous parliament the dotted grey line.


(And note I am being generous by including the possibly spurious figure for 2020-21.)

To maintain the level of spending in the last parliament, and up spending to 2.2% of GDP would mean increasing spending by 0.2 percentage points a year. That’s an increase in cash terms across the parliament of roughly £20bn. (NB GDP averages about £2 trillion across the parliament.)

So the Chancellor went a little over half way to meet the infrastructure spending of the last parliament. This isn’t a high bar –George Osborne’s plan A was to hack away at infrastructure spending.

But it’s a start.

4 Responses to Autumn Statement 2016: Chancellor goes a little way to meet his investment challenge

  1. Productivity and the #AutumnStatement: an antidote to Brexit?
    Nov 23rd 2016, 5:03 pm

    […] communications, and research and development. £23bn sounds like a lot of money; as Geoff has blogged elsewhere, it is actually less than it sounds, but it is a step in the right direction and so it […]

  2. An Autumn Statement for Everyone? Looks like we’ll have to wait for spring
    Nov 23rd 2016, 5:32 pm

    […] as Geoff Tily shows here  the level of public infrastructure spending is still below the level of the last parliament – […]

  3. This is still austerity, but not as we knew it
    Nov 28th 2016, 8:50 am

    […] billion is a start (see also here), but in the great scheme of things the government’s overall spending plans are still austerity. […]

  4. Household debt is higher than in 2008, is history repeating?
    Jan 8th 2017, 8:31 am

    […] has already made some welcome moves towards fiscal policy, however as my colleague pointed out last month, this is small beer compared to what is needed.  We need urgent action to increase job security […]